The supposed value of a humanities degree from Harvard?
OMG…this was my first thought on reading this article “Harvard Asks Alumni for Help With Humanities MOOC” published in yesterday’s Chronicle of Education. [I've just read it as I'm a little behind in my reading.] Wow is my response….and I’d agree with ssaulvolk, one of the commentators on the article called who wrote 10 hours ago “Good news for adjuncts who thought they were at the bottom of the academic barrel! Harvard has come up with an even lower category. Kudos to the university with the GNP-sized endowment.”
YES! Clearly Humanities graduates either need to be underpaid, undervalued and they are cheap i.e. free for service. What Harvard has indirectly stated is that people with degree in the humanities have little or no value. Why? Well, they’re clearly willing to work for nothing according to Harvard!! One has to wonder what value does a PhD in the humanities have? Clearly, not much. Way to go Harvard in setting the bar for the manner in which people with Humanities PhD and degrees ought to be treated. You’d hope that perhaps the university would be far more politer, less judgmental to its faculty and students, and alumni but obviously they’re’ worthless. If this is the case…what about the rest of us?? (I didn’t get my PhD from Harvard just in case you’re wondering.)
Humanities Ph.D. Plus
By Carl Straumsheim. Doomsayers about the job market for humanities Ph.D.s are everywhere. In response to a growing number of graduates unable to find a job in academe, seven universities are starting a new project to prepare students for a career that may lead them out of the classroom or into new kinds of classrooms. The initiative, known as the Praxis Network, will showcase how different institutions are using innovative approaches to expand humanities education to help other colleges and universities do the same. Of the seven institutions participating, Duke University, for example, offers a one-year program for Ph.D. students to help them develop digital skills. University College London is combining humanities and computer science in a master's degree program that involves both thesis writing and work placement. The City University of New York Graduate Center has doctoral fellows working with the provost to design a new website and serving as technical consultants for faculty members. Read more...
Il faut redonner toute leur place aux SHS
Professeur de philosophie et président de l’université Paris-Ouest-Nanterre-la-Défense depuis 2012, Jean-François Balaudé (@JFBalaude) est un fervent défenseur d’une université pluridisciplinaire qui laisse toute leur place aux sciences humaines et sociales. Pour autant il ne néglige pas les impératifs d’insertion professionnelle de ses étudiants. Rencontre avec un philosophe engagé dans la cité.
Olivier Rollot : Alors que les universités sont de plus en plus soumises à l’évaluation de leurs résultats vous avez estimé dans une tribune qu’alors que se profile une nouvelle loi sur l’enseignement supérieur « le besoin d’une vision d’ensemble du devenir de l’université s’impose ». Que doit-on attendre de l’université aujourd’hui?
Jean-François Balaudé : Je parle de responsabilité sociale des universités (RSU) pour corriger une vision trop fortement économiste de l’université, et marquer son inscription au cœur de la société de la connaissance. L’université n’est pas un élément parmi d’autres de cette dernière, mais elle est centrale dans la production et la diffusion des savoirs. Il importe de défendre ses spécificités et notamment cette approche critique qui caractérise tous les universitaires, et qui est propre à former des citoyens éclairés et responsables.
O. R : Quand on pense à votre université on pense avant tout aux sciences humaines et sociales (SHS). Mais l’université Paris Ouest Nanterre ne s’y résume pas?
J-F. B : L’essentiel de nos 34 000 étudiants sont inscrits dans les sciences humaines et sociales au sens large (lettres, lettres, droit, économie et gestion, histoire, psychologie, etc.) mais nous proposons également des cursus en mathématiques, informatique et sciences de l’ingénieur. Nous sommes donc bien, pour être exact, une université pluridisciplinaire. Suite de l'article...
Professor of philosophy and president of the University Paris-Ouest-Nanterre la Défense since 2012, Jean-François Balaudé (@ JFBalaude) is a staunch defender of a multidisciplinary university leaving their place to the social sciences and humanities. More...
Parsing the humanities
That’s right. That’s the irritating – and maybe for some nostalgic – ring of an old-fashioned modem connecting your computer to the Internet (with phonetics borrowed from The Atlantic).
Now, imagine yourself back in the era when that sound was a novelty, particularly in the quiet halls of an English or history department, where the loudest ambient noise up to that point may have been the quiet swish of pages turning. Or perhaps a pencil scraping lightly at their margins. If you were that reader, hearing that “ding” for the first time, you might have looked up from your book and wondered what exactly was going on. You might have heard the birth of a new discipline called the digital humanities.
For most digital humanities scholars, even that time-frame of the mid-1990s is a bit late. They date the field’s origins to well before modems and the Internet, although at first it didn’t really have a name until it was called humanities computing and later, digital humanities. Read more...
Why we undervalue a liberal arts education
Besieged Humanities, Worldwide
By Scott Jaschik. DUBAI -- If it's any comfort to humanities professors who feel that their jobs, budgets and disciplines are being threatened, they have colleagues facing the same challenges pretty much all over the world. That was the consensus of a session here at Going Global, the international education conference of the British Council. A panel of scholars discussed problems that they see for the humanities (and social sciences too), and panelists agreed that the threats faced by humanities departments are quite common around the world. And they worried not only about the cuts, but about the arguments being made about the humanities. In something of a surprise for such discussions, the only optimistic comments came from the dean of a business school. Read more...
Will the study of archaeology soon become a thing of the past?
Richard III's discovery showcased UK academia, says Michael Braddick. But as student demand for certain subjects falls, should we have grave concerns for our future knowledge base?
Finding Richard III (on the premises of Leicester social services no less) is testament to the ingenuity of archaeologists. Weaving together findings from historical analysis of texts with scientific analysis of the skeleton and the site, they have made an overwhelming case that these are the remains of the king. As a historian, I spend a lot of time trying to listen to the dead. Every now and then a curtain seems to be pulled aside and we hear them directly, and the feeling is very powerful. The way that the wounds to the skull match with one of the historical accounts of Richard's death did that for me: I was taken to Richard's final moments, as his helmet was lost and his attackers closed in, his horse gone or stuck in the mud, the moments in other words when he knew he had lost his kingdom and his life. That human connection is precious, and rare. This ingenious work has recovered an important part of our heritage and will no doubt have direct economic benefits. "The King under the Car Park", as Channel 4 had it, will no doubt stimulate our creative and heritage industries. Leicester University's archaeology department will, I hope, thrive on the publicity. Read more...
Liberal Arts Go Dutch
Arts students shouldn't subsidise university science
By Gervas Huxley. Are tuition fees paid by arts students being used to fund university science? If so it shows a striking lack of accountability, says Gervas Huxley.
In my last blog, I explained that arts and humanities are the only subjects to have benefited from the fee changes introduced by the coalition government, as they have seen an increase in funding per student. But many readers were quick to point out that the connection between the revenue that tuition fees attract and expenditure on tuition is tenuous to say the least. This is true. There is no guarantee that increased revenues from fees, especially for students studying arts, humanities and social sciences, will be spent on their own education. University finances permit multiple kinds of cross-subsidy: both between research and teaching, and between different disciplines. Precisely how the surplus generated by fees is spent will in practice depend on the outcome of a complex process of bargaining between competing parties. Read more...