By G. Rendell. A recent post to the Green Schools listserv asked whether sustainability folks at any other institution had good models for evaluating "triple bottom line" returns on investment. The writer said his school wanted to consider environmental and social, as well as traditional economic, returns when evaluating projects. But then he went on to list 8 or 10 different measures of economic return (ROI, IRR, net present value, simple payback, etc., etc., etc.) which proposed "triple bottom line" models had to address. Which, to my mind indicated that while environmental and social factors might technically enter into decision processes, economic factors were still in first, second and third place. In truth, I've never seen a purely economic project evaluation model which took into consideration all the various economic metrics this supposedly more-than-just-economic protocol seemed to be demanding. Read more...
5 Questions About Adaptive Learning Platforms
By Joshua Kim. How many of you have actually spent quality time in an adaptive learning platform?
Not me ... and I’m getting worried about this gap in my experience.
(Although Phil Hill’s post Differentiated, Personalized & Adaptive Learning: some clarity for EDUCAUSE was very helpful. Thanks Phil. Now everyone go visit MindWires).
My strong sense is that the next few years in edtech will be dominated by two inter-related trends. Read more...
Amazon's Whispersync, Reading and Higher Ed
By Joshua Kim. The real question is what you think about the relationship between consumer technology and higher ed?
Is higher ed competing with Amazon, Google, Facebook, etc. etc.?
What does that question even mean? What exactly are we competing for? Attention? Relevancy? Eyeballs? Dollars?
This is the framework that we should take into thinking about what Amazon’s Whispersync technology means for higher ed. Read more...
A Confession of Faith in Books
By Barbara Fister. I am a book person. I read a lot of them. I own a lot of them, and give a lot of them away I really like being in the stacks of my library, even though sometimes what I’m doing there is deciding which books shouldn't be there. I am a book person who is dismayed that it’s getting harder to share scholarship through the medium of books. It’s not that we aren’t publishing enough books, it’s that we still – stupidly – demand books as a token of productivity exchangeable for the chance at a regular living wage even as the traditional infrastructure for making books public is crumbling. Read more...
Unfunded Ph.D.s: To Go or Not To Go
By Natascha Chtena. When applying to Ph.D. programs, I was often advised to consider an acceptance without departmental funding as a polite rejection. I chose to pursue an unfunded Ph.D. regardless. Partly because I really wanted to go back to school, partly because I really wanted to work with my current advisor, partly because I really wanted to move to the States and this was an opportunity to do so. After securing partial funding from a private institution overseas, I felt empowered, special and, even, unbreakable. Read more...
How to (Not) Talk about Your Research
By Erin Bedford. It’s happened to the best of us. First, the question: “so, what is your research on?” Then, the blank stare as you try to explain. And finally, the uninterested but polite nod and smile. The other day, one of my past classmates asked me what I was working on. When I was given the blank stare from someone with an identical background to me, I realized that I have a problem. I’m tired of not being understood. No more hiding behind excuses like “my work is too complicated” or “they don’t actually care.” It’s time to figure out why we aren’t understood and what we can do to change that. What mistakes do we make when talking about our research? Read more...
Minimalist College: The Testing Floor
By John Lombardi. The ongoing pursuit of the cheapest and least intrusive higher education alternatives continues apace. Some find the activity new and exciting, although of course we’ve always been able to get educated by reading books and studying on our own. The new twist is that we can now sign up for computer mediated reading and studying on our own, a convenience in the fast-food tradition of highly efficient standardized production of useful commodity products. To guarantee the benefit of this form of higher education, we develop a battery of tests that ensure no student is left behind in the race to certification as an educated and competent adult. Many in the state-supported higher education policy realm see these tests as mechanisms to reduce the number of students in real universities and drive them through a fast food education that produces certification at a low cost, perhaps only $10K or less for a college diploma. Read more...
The Privilege of Not Examining Privilege
By Susan O'Doherty. Two friends have recently brought my attention to these articles, which explore some of the ways race and socioeconomic status can affect our experiences and thus our worldview. One could make a convincing argument that the "privilege" of receiving light penalties for serious mistakes is anything but a character builder. Kids whose parents bail them out of every scrape tend to become self-centered, irresponsible adults without a strong grasp of cause and effect. One could even speculate that some of the ignorant white teenagers in the first article might benefit from firsthand experience of the consequences of shopping, driving or walking while black, if only to sensitize them to all the behavior they, as members of a privileged class, routinely get away with. Read more...
Fearlessness and Lifelong Learning
A Revenge Scenario For Student Loan Borrowers
By Christina Fitzpatrick. Years ago, a troubled co-op board in Harlem rented me an apartment that was uninhabitable.
I wrote a few letters, stopped people in the laundry room, and tried to bargain kindly, until finally I went downtown to a courthouse. The woman who spoke to me was harried and tired. She asked three questions before concluding I had no rights in the matter. She shouted, “Next!”
Out of frustration, not willfulness, I stayed put. I kept talking. My eyes began to tear, then brim, like some damsel crashing a wedding with a gun.